News

Law

Asset Management

Investment Banking

Wealth

Hedge Funds

People

Newsletters

Events

Lists

Politics

Central banks in the dock but we cannot compromise their independence

They are under attack for missing their inflation targets, failing to maintain financial stability and for ignoring the global repercussions of their policies, but there are reasons central banks should remain independent

Standing out: there are reasons central banks should remain independent
Standing out: there are reasons central banks should remain independent Photo: Sean Gladwell / Getty Images

On November 11, 1997, the Bank of England took a big step toward independence, courtesy of the second reading in the House of Commons of a bill amending the Bank Act of 1946. The bill gave legislative affirmation to the decision, taken by then-Chancellor of the Exchequer Gordon Brown, to free central bank operations from governmental control. This was a landmark event for an institution that had been under the yoke of government for a half-century. It symbolised how the need for central bank independence had become conventional wisdom.

Now, however, this wisdom is being questioned, and not just in the UK. So long as inflation was the real and present danger, it made sense to delegate monetary policy to conservative central bankers insulated from pressure to finance government budget deficits. Today, in contrast, the problem is the opposite, namely the inability of central banks to raise inflation to target levels.

WSJ Logo